Tastefully Simple Top Alternatives and Competitors in 2026
Posted on |
Home › Comparisons › Tastefully Simple Alternatives and Competitors
By Mohamed Zaki · Researched and updated November 13, 2026 · Coupons Scout may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.
Looking for the Tastefully Simple top alternatives and competitors? Tastefully Simple is a strong pick for home cooks who want easy seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits, backed by its Love It Guarantee with a full refund of the purchase price. Penzeys Spices, Spiceology and Savory Spice each shine in different ways, from spice variety to BBQ rubs and everyday savings. We compared all four on prices, product range, gift sets, shipping, rewards and return policies, using the brands’ own pages as of November 2026.
Quick Answer
Tastefully Simple is our top pick for easy meal kits and dips: seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits in one shop, sale items from $5.99 (was $9.99), a free VIP Rewards program and a Love It Guarantee with a full refund of the purchase price. Choose Penzeys Spices for spice variety and sizes, Spiceology for BBQ rubs and variety packs, and Savory Spice for everyday savings and loyalty rewards.
Best for: Tastefully Simple suits home cooks who want quick, easy meals and a full-refund guarantee if a product is not a hit.
Key Takeaways
- The top Tastefully Simple alternatives in 2026 are Penzeys Spices, Spiceology and Savory Spice.
- As of November 2026, Tastefully Simple lists sale items from $5.99 (was $9.99) and Bountiful Beer Bread Mix at an $8.99, and its Love It Guarantee promises a full refund of the purchase price.
- As of November 2026, Penzeys Spices focuses on single spices and hand-mixed blends and says unopened mail-order products can be returned within 90 days for a full refund.
- As of November 2026, Spiceology lists All-Purpose Seasoning at $14.95 and offers free shipping on orders of $50 or more, but it does not accept returns on grocery products unless there is an error or defect.
- As of November 2026, Savory Spice has Savory Savings items under $7, free U.S. shipping on orders of $49 or more and a Loyalty Club where 100 points redeem for a $10 reward.
Tastefully Simple Top Alternatives and Competitors at a Glance
| Brand | Best for | Main products | Returns | Our score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tastefully Simple | Easy seasonings, dips and meal kits | Seasonings, sauces, dips, meal kits | Love It Guarantee (full refund) | 4.3/5 |
| Penzeys Spices | Wide spice and blend range | Spices, hand-mixed blends, gift boxes | Unopened mail order: full refund in 90 days | 4.5/5 |
| Spiceology | Bold rubs and gift-ready variety packs | Spices, BBQ rubs, variety packs | No grocery returns; errors/defects fixed | 4.2/5 |
| Savory Spice | Everyday savings and loyalty rewards | Spices, blends, salts, gift collections | Defective/damaged exchange within 30 days | 4.4/5 |
From the pricing page of each brand on November 13, 2026. Taxes and regional prices can change the total.
Winners by Category
- Best for easy meal kits and dips: Tastefully Simple (seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits with a full-refund Love It Guarantee).
- Best for single spices and blends: Penzeys Spices (unopened mail-order returns within 90 days).
- Best for BBQ rubs and variety packs: Spiceology (Ultimate Rub Collection of 12 mini rub jars).
- Best for everyday spice savings: Savory Spice (Savory Savings items under $7, free U.S. shipping from $49).
Why Look for a Tastefully Simple Alternative?
Do You Want Single Spices in Many Sizes?
Tastefully Simple sells seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits in one shop. If you cook from scratch and want single spices and herbs, Penzeys Spices focuses on single spices and hand-mixed blends.
Are You Shopping for a Griller?
Spiceology makes spices, seasoning blends and BBQ rubs. It sells an Ultimate Rub Collection of 12 mini rub jars and a Top 8 Seasonings Variety Pack. Tastefully Simple also has a Garlic Garlic Seasoning Value Pack listed at $20.99.
Is Free Shipping a Priority?
According to its FAQ, Tastefully Simple charges $10.99 for ground shipping to the 48 contiguous states on orders up to $64.99 and 15% of the total on orders of $65 or more. Savory Spice ships free on U.S. orders of $49 or more and Spiceology ships free on orders of $50 or more. If you shop Tastefully Simple, combine items into one cart and check our Tastefully Simple coupon page for current offers.
How We Compared the Tastefully Simple Alternatives
We read each company’s own pricing, feature, help and policy pages on November 13, 2026, and scored each tool on five points:
- Range: seasonings, mixes, sauces and gift sets each brand lists.
- Ingredients: ingredient and label notes each brand describes, as the brand says.
- Value: listed prices, sales and bundle offers on each brand’s own pages.
- Policies: returns, warranty and guarantee terms on each brand’s policy pages.
- Shipping: delivery terms and free shipping rules each brand publishes.
Scores reflect this research, not a sponsorship, and no company reviewed this article. Where we earn a commission, it never changes the ranking.
How Much Do Tastefully Simple and Its Alternatives Cost?
Seasoning prices vary by product, size and sale, so the table shows one sample item from each shop as listed on its own pages rather than a full basket total. For anything not shown, see the pricing page of each brand.
| Brand | Example item | Listed price |
|---|---|---|
| Tastefully Simple | Bountiful Beer Bread Mix | $8.99 |
| Penzeys Spices | Penzeys Seasoned Salt | See brand page |
| Spiceology | All-Purpose Seasoning | $14.95 |
| Savory Spice | Premium Finishing Salt | $5.99 |
Calculated from the prices shown on the brand pages on November 13, 2026. Taxes and regional prices can change the total.
1. Tastefully Simple: Best for Easy Meal Kits and Dips
Best for: home cooks who want easy seasonings, dips and meal kits backed by a full-refund guarantee · Starting price: Sale items from $5.99 (was $9.99); Bountiful Beer Bread Mix $8.99 · Our score: 4.3/5
Tastefully Simple sells seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits. The company describes its products as made with clean labels and healthy living in mind. Its shop lists items such as Bountiful Beer Bread Mix at $8.99 and the Garlic Garlic Seasoning Value Pack at $20.99, and a sales page shows marked-down items. A free VIP Rewards program lets shoppers earn points toward free products. A free TS Ambassador program lets fans share a personalized link and earn based on sales.
Sale items on its sales page start at $5.99, down from $9.99. According to its FAQ, ground shipping to the 48 contiguous states costs $10.99 on orders up to $64.99 and 15% of the total on orders of $65 or more. Most orders are processed within 1-3 business days. The Love It Guarantee promises a full refund of the purchase price if you are not satisfied; you contact your TS Ambassador or the help email to use it. See Tastefully Simple coupons.
✅ What We Like
- Love It Guarantee with a full refund of the purchase price
- Sale items from $5.99
- Free VIP Rewards program that earns points toward free products
- Seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits in one shop
- Most orders processed within 1-3 business days
💡 Things to Consider
- Shipping is charged on every order (15% of totals of $65 or more), so combine purchases into one cart
- The shipping address cannot be changed after ordering, so double-check it at checkout
- Orders cannot be canceled once fulfilled or shipped, so review your cart before paying
2. Penzeys Spices: Best for Spice Variety and Sizes
Best for: cooks who want a wide range of single spices and hand-mixed blends · Starting price: See Penzeys’ own pages for current jar and bag prices · Our score: 4.5/5
Penzeys Spices sells single spices, herbs and hand-mixed seasoning blends such as Sunny Paris, Fox Point and Arizona Dreaming, plus trial bags and gift boxes, including a custom gift box builder. The company runs free-spice promotions, such as free quarter-cup jars with a $10 purchase in its retail stores, and offers a free Penzeys Monthly editorial subscription plus recipe emails.
Penzeys notes that pricing and promotional savings may vary by location. Its return policy says unopened mail-order products can be returned within 90 days for a full refund, and if you are not satisfied with a product bought in the last 180 days it will replace the item or help you find something else.
✅ What We Like
- Full refund on unopened mail-order products within 90 days
- Satisfaction help on products bought in the last 180 days
- Single spices and hand-mixed blends
- Frequent free-spice promotions with qualifying purchases
- Custom gift boxes and trial bags
💡 Things to Consider
- Free promotional items cannot be returned or exchanged, so treat them as a bonus
- Web and phone orders cannot be refunded at retail stores, so contact the call center instead
- Pricing and promotions may vary by location, so check your cart total before paying
3. Spiceology: Best for BBQ Rubs and Variety Packs
Best for: grillers and gift shoppers who like bold rubs and variety packs · Starting price: Spices include All-Purpose Seasoning at $14.95 · Our score: 4.2/5
Spiceology makes spices, seasoning blends and BBQ rubs, sold on its website and at retailers across the country. Its range includes single spices such as coarse black pepper, all-purpose seasonings and variety packs like the Ultimate Rub Collection of 12 mini rub jars and a BBQ Rubs Variety Pack of 8 top seasoning blends. Its site quotes Forbes calling it ‘the best gift for spice lovers.’
Listed prices include All-Purpose Seasoning at $14.95, and the shop also sells an Ultimate Rub Collection of 12 mini rub jars and a Top 8 Seasonings Variety Pack. Shipping is free on orders of $50 or more. According to its FAQ, Spiceology cannot accept returns or exchanges on grocery products, but if it makes an error or a product is defective it will issue a refund or replacement. Optional Route shipping protection can cover reorders or refunds for package issues.
✅ What We Like
- Free shipping on orders of $50 or more
- Variety packs of rubs and seasonings for gifting
- Refund or replacement for order errors and defects
💡 Things to Consider
- Grocery products cannot be returned or exchanged, so start with a variety pack to sample flavors
- Orders may not be changeable after placement, so review your cart first
- The Route Premium cost is not refunded, so decide if you need shipping protection
4. Savory Spice: Best for Everyday Spice Savings
Best for: budget-minded cooks who want everyday savings and loyalty rewards · Starting price: Savory Savings items under $7; Premium Finishing Salt $5.99 · Our score: 4.4/5
Savory Spice sells spices, seasoning blends, extracts, finishing salts and gift collections online and in its own stores, with free in-store pickup. Its shop lists items such as The Ultimate Signature Collection and a Gourmet Hot Cocoa Kit, and its Savory Savings collection includes 50+ pantry staples and best sellers priced under $7. Shoppers buying larger amounts get 10% off two bags and 15% off three bags of the same product in the largest size. The free Loyalty Club earns 1 point per $1, and 100 points redeem for a $10 reward or free products.
Listed prices include Premium Finishing Salt at $5.99, the Gourmet Hot Cocoa Kit at $42.00 and The Ultimate Signature Collection at $75.00. According to its FAQ, shipping is a flat $8 on orders up to $49 and free on U.S. orders of $49 or more, and most orders arrive within 5 days. Loyalty Club members also get a free Refill Bag spice blend in their birthday month. Its return policy says defective or damaged food items may be exchanged within 30 days of purchase.
✅ What We Like
- Savory Savings items priced under $7
- Free U.S. shipping on orders of $49 or more
- 10% off two bags and 15% off three bags of the same product
- Free Loyalty Club with a $10 reward per 100 points
- Free birthday Refill Bag and free in-store pickup
💡 Things to Consider
- Food returns cover defective or damaged items within 30 days, so check your order on arrival
- Points expire after 1 year and rewards after 30 days, so redeem them promptly
- Only one reward per order and rewards cannot be combined with other discounts, so pick the bigger saving
How to Choose Between Tastefully Simple and Its Alternatives
How Do You Like to Cook?
If you want dinner on the table with little prep, Tastefully Simple’s seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits are built for that, and the company says its products are made with clean labels and healthy living in mind. If you prefer building flavors yourself, Penzeys Spices offers single spices, herbs and hand-mixed blends, Savory Spice offers spices, blends, extracts and finishing salts, and Spiceology sells spices, seasoning blends and BBQ rubs.
Which Return Policy Fits You Best?
Tastefully Simple’s Love It Guarantee promises a full refund of the purchase price if you are not satisfied. Penzeys Spices says unopened mail-order products can be returned within 90 days for a full refund, and that it will replace or help with products bought in the last 180 days. Spiceology issues a refund or replacement for errors and defects, and Savory Spice exchanges defective or damaged food items within 30 days. If you want to try a new flavor, Tastefully Simple’s Love It Guarantee promises a full refund of the purchase price if you are not satisfied, while the other three limit refunds to unopened items or errors and defects on the pages we read.
Do Loyalty Programs Matter to You?
Tastefully Simple’s free VIP Rewards program earns points toward free products, and its free TS Ambassador program lets fans share a personalized link and earn based on sales. Savory Spice’s free Loyalty Club earns 1 point per $1, with 100 points redeeming for a $10 reward or free products, and members also get a free Refill Bag spice blend in their birthday month. Penzeys Spices runs free-spice promotions, such as a free jar with a $10 purchase.
Which Shop Is Best for Gifts?
Penzeys Spices offers gift boxes and a custom gift box builder, Spiceology sells variety packs, and Savory Spice lists collections such as The Ultimate Signature Collection at $75.00. Tastefully Simple lists the Garlic Garlic Seasoning Value Pack at $20.99 alongside its seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits.
Can You Save with a Coupon?
Yes. Before you check out, visit our Tastefully Simple coupons page; it lists current codes and offers, so click Get Code to apply the discount. Also browse the Tastefully Simple sales page, where sale items start at $5.99.
Final Thoughts
For home cooks who want easy seasonings, dips and meal kits with a full-refund Love It Guarantee, Tastefully Simple is the best fit on this list, with sale items from $5.99 and a free VIP Rewards program. If you want a wide range of spices in many sizes, try Penzeys Spices; for BBQ rubs and gift-ready variety packs, try Spiceology; and for everyday savings and loyalty rewards, try Savory Spice. Read our Tastefully Simple review for more detail.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Tastefully Simple alternatives?
The top Tastefully Simple alternatives in 2026 are Penzeys Spices (spice variety and sizes), Spiceology (BBQ rubs and variety packs) and Savory Spice (everyday savings and loyalty rewards). Tastefully Simple remains our pick for easy meal kits and dips.
Is Tastefully Simple better than Penzeys Spices?
It depends on how you cook. As of November 2026, Tastefully Simple offers seasonings, sauces, dips and meal kits with a full-refund Love It Guarantee and sale items from $5.99, while Penzeys Spices focuses on single spices and hand-mixed blends, with a 90-day refund on unopened mail-order products.
Which seasoning shop offers free shipping?
As of November 2026, Savory Spice ships free on U.S. orders of $49 or more and Spiceology ships free on orders of $50 or more. According to its FAQ, Tastefully Simple charges $10.99 for ground shipping to the 48 contiguous states on orders up to $64.99 and 15% of the total on orders of $65 or more, so check the shipping cost before you pay.
Which shop has the best satisfaction guarantee?
As of November 2026, Tastefully Simple’s Love It Guarantee promises a full refund of the purchase price if you are not satisfied. Penzeys Spices refunds unopened mail-order items within 90 days, Spiceology fixes errors and defects, and Savory Spice exchanges defective or damaged food within 30 days.
Which alternative is best for BBQ rubs?
Spiceology is the strongest pick for BBQ rubs among these four, with an Ultimate Rub Collection of 12 mini rub jars and a Top 8 Seasonings Variety Pack on its site as of November 2026.
Are there Tastefully Simple promo codes?
Yes. Our Tastefully Simple coupon page lists current promo codes and offers. Click Get Code on the page so the discount is applied at checkout.
About the author: Mohamed Zaki, Founder & Chief MarTech Strategist, Coupons Scout. Mohamed Zaki is the founder of Coupons Scout and leads how the team finds deals and researches the software behind them. He focuses on marketing technology, automation tools and ways to pay less for them.
Editorial note: this article is based on research of brand product pages, help centers and policies, last checked November 13, 2026. Scores are our editorial opinion. Coupons Scout may earn a commission from some links, which never changes our rankings.
Sources
Brand pages we used for this article, checked November 13, 2026. Prices and plans can change, so confirm on the brand’s own website before you buy.
- Tastefully Simple: homepage
- Tastefully Simple: Terms of use
- Tastefully Simple: Guarantee
- Penzeys Spices: homepage
- Spiceology: homepage
- Savory Spice: homepage
- Savory Spice: Terms of service
- Tastefully Simple: Sales
- Tastefully Simple: Shop
- Penzeys Spices: H15 web optimized.pdf
- Penzeys Spices: Return policy
- Savory Spice: Common questions
- Tastefully Simple: Faq
